I have the following reactions to the election. I did in point of fact vote for Senator John McCain, and for the reason I stated in February. I would honestly vote for General Colin Powell or some other person of color with actual military experience.
Questions I want answered
1. How many votes were conducted by people who shouldn't have voted (thank you ACORN)
2. How many people were scared to vote against Senator Obama out of fear of being called racists?
3. Why the heck were the Mormons allowed to erode church-state separation to get the backward bigotry known as Proposition 8 passed in California?
4. When will Washington D.C. finally remember they serve We the People, and not the other way around?
5. When will the Congress remember that they have a duty under Article 1, Section 8, paragraph 1 to get rid of our national debt, not make it bigger?
How to legalize gay marriage safely
I am a Lutheran, and as such I am entitled to function as my own priest. My personal theology is based primarily off of the commandments of Jesus of Nazareth, with the rest of the Bible coming after that. I reject the majority of the taboos in the Law of Moses as inappropriate for the modern age, with the specific exceptions of the bestiality and incest taboos.
I believe that gay marriage ought to be legalized. To fail to do so continues a tradition in Western culture of creating "separate but equal" sets of rights on the basis of sexual orientation. Our country's experience with public schools shows that separate is inherently unequal. The prevailing scientific opinion is that sexual orientation is partially nature, partially nurture. It is natural in that, at least in gay guys, the anterior commissure, a nerve cluster in the brain, is wired differently from how straight guys' brains are wired.
The conservative Christians have a series of complaints against the notion of gay marriage:
1. According to them, the Bible establishes one-man, one-woman marriage as the tradition, which everyone must follow. Legalizing gay marriage would threaten this tradition.
2. Legalizing gay marriage would leave churches and religious authorities open to lawsuit or criminal prosecution, when they must answer to their consciences and to the Almighty.
3. Legalizing gay marriage would pave the way for a legalization of polygamy, bestiality, adult incest, and other abhorrent practices.
4. Homosexuality is a disease, and gay couples would corrupt the youth and make it less likely for people to do their Biblical duty and reproduce.
I believe that all of these complaints can be safely addressed.
First, the Bible neither prohibits nor commands that gay marriage be established in explicit language. Therefore, the gay marriage opponents do not have a leg to stand on, as far as I'm concerned. As a Christian, I believe that Matthew 22:39 "Love thy neighbor as thyself" takes precedence over any efforts to exclude this minority group or that from full participation as equal members of society, with individual exceptions for criminals and the like. The Biblical definition of adultery does not specifically include homosexual intercourse.
The story of Sodom and Gomorrah in Genesis does not explicitly refer to homosexuality. It instead refers to general wickedness on the part of the inhabitants of those two cities. The people of Sodom had so little respect for the laws of hospitality that they tried to rape Lot's guests, the two angels. Anal rape and vaginal rape are equally wrong.
The verse Leviticus 18:22 "Do not lie with a man as one lies with a woman; this is detestable" is the key Biblical homosexuality taboo. But this specific verse, as with any Biblical verse, can be interpreted in any number of ways. It could prohibit all homosexual sex, or it could hold blanket toleration for lesbianism while gay couples are merely prohibited from using the 'missionary' position. The
The Bible does not specifically say that one form of marriage is preferential to another. The three patriarchs of Israel--Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob--all had one or more wives and one or more concubines. King Solomon had hundreds of wives. The Jewish tradition of the midrash says that Adam had one wife, Lilith, who turned to evil, and therefore God made Eve from Adam's rib. The Bible does not specifically say: "Each man must have one and only one wife" in any verse in my awareness.
The Bible also contains, I believe, a story of consensual love between two young men. This story concerns David (he wasn't King David yet) and Jonathan, the son of King Saul. It starts in Samuel 18:1-4, when Jonathan strips naked in front of David (ancient Israelites did not have underwear). This encounter takes place when they have just met, the night after David kills Goliath, when that teen is probably still on an adrenaline rush, which would make him eager for comfort, especially since the dreadful Goliath was David's first intelligent kill. In 1 Samuel 20:41, the two are described as kissing, which may be simply a good-bye or may be more. Their relationship unfortunately ends with the death of Saul and Jonathan. In his lament for the two, King David says "I grieve for you, Jonathan my brother; you were very dear to me. Your love for me was wonderful, more wonderful than that of women" (2 Samuel 1:26). The word 'brother' could be a sort of code-word for "male lover."
Pursuant to the second complaint, the act of Congress legalizing gay marriage can be worded properly: "The right of two consenting adults to enjoy the full legal benefits of marriage shall not be denied on the basis of sexual orientation. Religious organizations and their representatives shall be protected henceforth from all civil suit or criminal prosecution for refusing for reasons of conscience or creed to perform such ceremonies." We need to remember, ladies and gentlemen, that the Free Exercise Clause protects almost all forms of religious expression, even those we do not agree with. Human sacrifice is not protected, being abhorrent to all but the most foul religions.
Banning gay marriage violates the Establishment Clause, being excessive entanglement between religious and secular authorities, favoring religion. In order to protect the Free Exercise rights of conservative Christians, they must be granted blanket immunity from prosecution. Otherwise, cases will clog our courts, who have much more important things to be dealing with.
Pursuant to the third complaint, we can again add specific language in the second paragraph of the Gay Marriage legalization act. "The Federal Courts of the United States, and the Courts of the several States, are hereby instructed to dismiss all suits which may arise seeking to use this law to legalize bestiality, pedophilia, adult incest, polygamy, these acts being detrimental to the public morals."
Pursuant to the fourth complaint, homosexuality is not a disease. The American Psychological Association removed it from a list of mental illnesses in 1973, and they obviously know what they're talking about. Where is the proof that children raised by homosexuals are predisposed to be homosexuals themselves?
No comments:
Post a Comment